Moka Pot vs Percolator: which coffee maker brew better?

Moka pot vs percolator

Finding the right coffee maker for your kitchen countertop isn’t a herculean task anymore. Many coffee makers are available with so many features. Every coffee maker has its unique quality and function. Moka pot vs percolator, And you have the choice to compare and pick the best brewer.

Moka pot and Percolator make robust and flavorful coffee with specific differences in the brewing process. These stovetop coffee makers deliver the perfect brewing experience. Also, these classic brewing devices have been around for decades, each boasting its unique brewing technique and distinctive flavors.

If you are a new coffee enthusiast, you will probably like these coffee makers because both use simple but effective methods to give fantastic coffee.

The primary focus of this article is to give you the clear differences between the two and give suggestions if you are planning to buy a coffee maker. Let’s first check what these stovetop coffee makers are and how they brew perfect coffee cups.

What is a Percolator coffee maker?

percolator coffee maker

Percolator is a traditional and used old brewing method. It works well by following simple steps. Percolator coffee maker is aesthetically designed and has various varieties.

In today’s world, where automated coffee machines dominate the market, brewing coffee with a percolator seems outdated for a few. But reality is many still prefer it over modern coffee machines due to its consistent brewing technique.

Percolator makes smooth coffee without adding flavors. The taste depends on what type of ground coffee and what type of brewing method is being followed. But Percolator brews different tastes compared to other coffee brewers.

How to make coffee in a Percolator?

Like any old-fashioned brewing machine, a percolator brews with traditional methods. However, Percolator is designed to make coffee in large volumes.

I would suggest using fresh coffee beans in Percolator. Because fresh coffee can give an amazing taste and aroma.

And coarse grind should be the preferred option for Percolator. But it is not necessary to use fresh beans; any type of ground coffee works fine.

  • First, disassemble every part of the Percolator.
  • Fill the bottom chamber with water. But remember, fill the water according to the given indicator. As we know that 6 ounces of water is used in 1 tablespoon of coffee. But you can make strong coffee by adding more water or less strong coffee by adding more water in 1 spoon of ground coffee.
  • In the next step, Add the ground coffee to the Percolator’s filter.
  • Now, it’s time to reassemble the Percolator, ensuring all parts are securely in place.
  • Place the Percolator on the stove and turn the heat on. Here it is important to remember whenever brewing coffee, try to put it on medium heat. The medium heat brews perfect coffee on the stovetop.
  • When water starts boiling, it is being forced to the ground.
  • Remove the Percolator from the heat source.
  • Let the brewed coffee settle for a minute or two. This allows any remaining coffee grounds to sink to the bottom of the Percolator.
  • Coffee is ready to pour into the cup and enjoy.

What is Moka Pot?

Moka pot coffee maker

There is not much between the Moka pot and Percolator when it comes to design, and the brewing technique is concerned. When compared to Percolator, the Moka pot is a reasonably new creation. Moka pot was developed in the 1930s by an Italian. It is specifically designed to make robust and flavorful coffee.

What I like the most about Moka pot are the simplest brewing method and the robust taste. It has a different taste to espresso, but the intensity of the coffee flavor is almost the same. So if you want anything similar strong taste of espresso, the Moka pot should be your preferred option.

Moka pot is available in sizes from single cups to large volumes.

How to make coffee in a Moka pot?

Almost all coffee makers brew similarly. There are only slight differences during brewing, like the French press or Percolator.

The Moka pot consists of three main parts: a bottom chamber for water, a middle chamber for ground coffee, and a top chamber for brewed coffee.

The water is used to fill with water. And the middle chamber uses to add finely ground coffee. So when the Moka pot is set on the stovetop, the water at the lower chamber gets hot, creates pressure, and water passes through the middle chamber, where it passes through the ground coffee and to the upper chamber.

The coffee is ready when the hot water arrives in the upper chamber.

Which coffee beans are suitable for a Moka pot?

Like many other coffee makers, I would recommend you pick medium-roasted coffee beans for the Moka pot. The brewing method of the Moka pot produces strong coffee, so medium-roasted coffee beans deliver a perfect taste.

Also, if you want bold coffee close to espresso, use espresso roast because darkly roasted coffee beans are specifically made for an intense coffee taste.

You can go for Colombian coffee beans if you want a smoother taste. These Colombian beans are medium roasted, which will give a slightly sweeter taste.

Moka pot and coarse grind

What are the differences between Moka Pot vs Percolator?

These two fine-quality coffee makers have differences in the brewing process, taste and design.

Difference in Design

Apparently, they look similar in design and structure. But then a definite difference in the structure of the Moka pot and Percolator.

I like The Moka Pot because it has a compact design with good built quality. It has three chambers: the top chamber contains the end coffee, the middle chamber works as a filter, and the bottom chamber is where the water is poured.

While the Percolator is slightly larger in size and more cylindrical. And the Percolator has additional components like the central tube and holed lid.

So the design differences influence how water and coffee interact during the brewing process, resulting in variations in flavor and strength of the brewed coffee.

Moka Pot vs Percolator: Differences in the Brewing Process

Both brewers have different brewing methods. However, none of them needs any expertise to brew coffee. Percolator has a similar brewing process to espresso, where hot water passes through ground coffee.

On the other hand, a Percolator is quite similar to a drip coffee maker. It works through a cycle of water rising up the central tube and then dripping down through the coffee grounds repeatedly. This process continues until the desired strength is achieved.

These different brewing processes resulted in significant differences in taste and aroma.

Difference in taste

Moka pot brews a robust bitter taste with a strong aroma. It tastes somewhere near to the taste of espresso, but it can’t reach the intensity of espresso. When compared to Percolator, the Moka pot brews concentrated, rich, flavor coffee.

Percolator is a more traditional coffee maker; it brews less strong coffee. I think it tastes quite similar to brewed coffee. If you want milder coffee, the Percolator is a better choice.


Final thoughts: Moka Pot vs Percolator, which brewer is best suitable for you?

As for picking the right coffee brewer for your kitchen, set your priorities and choose one coffee maker that best suits you. I can only give the right direction and elaborate on the difference between Percolator and Moka pot.

Since there is not much difference in the price category of these coffee makers, only pick the brewer based on the brewing method and the flavor of the coffee.

If you’re a coffee enthusiast, you should know that flavor and aroma is the primary factor in picking a coffee maker. Moka pot brews a robust and flavorful coffee, unlike Percolator, which brews a milder coffee with a slightly sweeter taste.

Moka pot is a comprehensive device that brews robust coffee similar to espresso because it has a similar brewing technique. So Moka pot is a better option, in my opinion.

Check this related Article.

Cold brew vs French press: get to know all the differences

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *